Spending all day driving screws is a tiring job, especially if the tool you're using to do it is bulky and heavy. Lightweight electric screwdrivers are designed to make the task easier, but they do so by sacrificing much of the power and versatility of an electric drill. If your to-do list includes more than just screw driving, a capable cordless drill is probably a better choice for your tool kit than a cordless electric screwdriver.
Torque is a measurement of twisting force, and the amount of torque that a tool produces is an indicator of the tasks it's capable of accomplishing. In general, lightweight electric screwdrivers tend to use less powerful, lower voltage motors than many cordless drills, so they may not be up heavy-duty tasks such as driving long lag screws into hardwood. Cordless drills with 18-V or 20-V motors, on the other hand, can handle just about any screw-driving task.
Size and Weight
The power of a heavy-duty cordless drill typically comes at the cost of extra weight. Professional-level cordless drills may weigh in excess of 6 pounds, making them wearisome to use for long periods of time. Less powerful drills are lighter, but few of them can match the weight advantage of electric screwdrivers, many of which weigh less than a pound. Electric screwdrivers are generally small, too, and many models will fit in a roomy pocket.
Versatility and Maneuverability
The small size and light weight of electric screwdrivers make them relatively nimble compared to most drills. They're ideal for driving screws in tight spaces, and many models feature adjustable angled drive heads for even better maneuverability. For overall versatility, however, the specialized nature of an electric screwdriver limits its usefulness compared to a drill, which can do much more than just drive screws; electric screwdrivers can drill small holes in soft woods, but their drilling capacity is limited.
In terms of monetary cost vs. tool capability, electric screwdrivers don't necessarily compare well with electric drills. The least expensive electric screwdrivers cost less than heavy-duty cordless drills, but more expensive screwdriver models typically cost more than inexpensive drills that are more powerful and more versatile.
Evan Gillespie grew up working in his family's hardware and home-improvement business and is an experienced gardener. He has been writing on home, garden and design topics since 1996. His work has appeared in the South Bend Tribune, the Fort Wayne Journal-Gazette, Arts Everywhere magazine and many other publications.