20 New Holiday Finds From Michaels Under $25 That Feel Like They Should Cost $50

For the holiday-obsessed, it's never too early to start thinking about decorating. Whether you observe Christmas, Hanukkah, New Year's, or any other winter occasion, this is truly the season of more is more. However, with a lot of uncertainty in the air, Americans in particular are looking to spend a bit — and some substantially — less on holiday decor than they have in previous years. While thrifting and creative DIYs can help you save, they won't always let you access the newest styles. Fortunately, crafts superstore chain Michaels has dropped its 2026 holiday collection under its own in-house brand, Ashland, and many of the items are under $25, with some currently on sale for 10% to 40% off. And trust us, they look like they'd cost double that, easily. 

From mantle accessories to candles and party goods, we present 20 finds for your holiday decorating and entertaining needs that look more expensive than they actually are. Consider combining any of these with easy holiday DIY projects, and your decor will look anything but budget-conscious. 

Nothing says whimsical Christmas quite like reindeer — except, maybe, Santa — and this Gold Metal Reindeer Tabletop Decor does it in style: The matte gold–finished iron figurine combines an intricate outline with a lack of detail, making it particularly well suited to modern, minimalist interiors. Available in three sizes, from 11.5 inches to 24 inches tall, the current sale price starts at $22.49.

Available in four sizes, from 12 to 30 inches tall, the Pre-Lit Faux Mercury Tabletop Tree replicates the appearance of mercury glass for a luxe look and feel not just on tables, but also on mantels, shelves, and bookcases. When switched on, interior LED lights that run on three AA batteries (not included) add festive twinkle. Currently on sale, prices start at $17.99 for the 12-inch tree.

Depending on the make and brand, birch candles can be eye-wateringly expensive. (Pottery Barn offers a flameless birch candle for $169!) Thankfully, Michaels has a respectable dupe, albeit smaller: Its 4-by-8-inch Birch LED Wax Pillar Candle is on sale for a more budget-friendly $14.99. Two smaller pillar sizes are available, an assortment of which would look fabulous atop a mantel or dining table. Michaels also offers 11-inch Birch LED Wax Taper Candles, which come in a two-pack for $11.99 (sale price).

With a ring of gold-tinted cutout trees and a warm wood (that's really MDF) surface, the 12-Inch Gold Tree Tray gives off rustic holiday season vibes. Use it solely as a decorative tray to corral objects, ornaments, or a cluster of LED pillar candles, or to create a charming presentation of cocoa, cocktails, and aperitifs on the table. One word of caution if doing the latter: The tray isn't made for direct contact with food, so don't use it in place of a cheeseboard or cake stand! The tray is currently on sale for $14.99.

Create a classy centerpiece or fireplace display by grouping ornaments, picture frames, candles, garland, or a floral arrangement around this Glass Finial Tabletop Decor. Finished in a frosted taupe shade and with a timeless silhouette, this piece absolutely looks high-end. The finial comes in three sizes, from 15 to 22 inches high, with sale prices starting at $17.99.

Jonathan Adler has designed a limited-edition Hanukkah collection for 2026. The line includes a striking acrylic menorah, ceramic dishware, and various objets d'art, such as the Jonathan Adler x Michaels Acrylic Dreidels – you can snag a pair for for $9.99, or a 4-pack for $19.99. Modern with a hint of Miami deco glam, they display the traditional Hebrew letter on each face. Learn more about the traditional Jewish symbols and what they mean in our informative guide.

Michaels offers a range of stocking holders for the mantel, but it's the adorable new 7.75-Inch Antique Gold Reindeer Stocking Holder that caught our attention. It is currently on sale for $17.99, but its weighty aluminum-and-iron construction and antique finish make it look and feel much more upscale. Pair it with the playful Antique Gold Nutcracker Stocking Holder, which is on sale for the same price. Or check out these other stocking holder ideas to mix and match styles.

You may have the pine branches and poinsettias set atop the dinner table, but feel like something is missing. Try combining the florals with this Gold Metal Circle Taper Candle Holder — on sale for $11.99 — to create a fuller, more dramatic centerpiece that also enhances nighttime ambience. If you're tired of all the gold trimmings, there's also a black metal version available.

If you're looking for a stylish vessel to serve spirits, wine, or even water at your holiday dinner party, consider the 40.05-Ounce Light Blue Etched Glass Decanter. Measuring 3.58 inches wide by 9.33 inches tall, it features an etched diamond-grid pattern mingled with stars. Though it's described as "light blue," it appears to have a deep teal tone, giving it a luxe appearance that makes it seem more expensive than its $22.49 sale price tag.

A fun — and pretty — way to mark each night of Hanukkah, the Hanukkah Ceramic Table Countdown costs $24.99. It consists of a 13.9-inch-wide sawtooth ceramic base and a light blue–painted wooden dreidel. Move the dreidel from notch to notch; each is labeled with the number of nights above an illustration of a menorah, doves, and florals.

Don't forget to pick up candles for your menorah. These Hanukkah Candles come in a pack of 45 for $16.99 and have a delightful, eye-catching honeycomb texture. The set includes dark blue, light blue, and white pieces, with each paraffin-and-palm-wax candle measuring 4.4 inches high.

Those who enjoy seasonal home fragrances might appreciate this Pine Greenery Warm Vanilla Reed Diffuser, which comes with a faceted glass diffuser, a glass cloche cover, 5.41 fluid ounces of vanilla fragrance oil, six wood reeds, and a decorative pine sprig and cone. And once the fragrance oil is gone, you can replace it and keep this pretty piece on display. It's currently on sale for $14.99.

Perfect for a tabletop, mantel, or even around the tree skirt, this Gold Lighted Glass Tree adds refined Christmas cheer and subtle sparkle, both from its reflective finish and interior LED lights. It comes in three sizes, from 3.5 by 7.6 inches to 5 by 12.9 inches. With current sale prices starting at $14.99, you might consider getting one of each for a shimmering display. 

Appropriately part of Michaels' Merry Kitschmas collection, the 6-Inch Ceramic Animal Dessert Plates depict four different wildlife stars: a koala, cheetah, leopard, and zebra, each sporting a holiday accessory. Use these to plate dessert or appetizers for young — or young-at-heart — houseguests, or as winter decor. You can hang them on the wall, set them in small plate display holders, or leave them on a table as a trinket tray. This plate set is currently on sale for $17.99.

Concealed within a fluted white marble container, the 9-Ounce Evergreen Noel Scented Candle looks more expensive than it actually is. Offered on sale at $22.49, its jar is worthy of repurposing for DIY candles, small storage, or keepsakes once you've burned down the existing evergreen-scented candle. 

A suitable vase for faux holiday or dried florals, the Gold Hammered Metal Decor Container is a home accessory that looks non-holiday enough to use year-round. You can even leave it empty, letting the textured metallic finish stand on its own. It's offered in three sizes — 3.95 by 6.85 inches, 6.7 by 9.85 inches, and 8.85 by 13 inches — with the largest container perfectly proportioned for bigger bushes and small trees. These containers aren't rated for use with liquids, so don't use them for live, watered arrangements. Sale pricing starts at $13.49 for the small size.

A way to add holiday cheer through sight and sound, this Hanging Bell is a charming oversized decorative object that's ready to chime in. Finished in a bronze tone with a faux-leather hand strap, it looks great hanging from a mantel, paired with a wreath, on a coat hook in the foyer, or even sitting on a tabletop or shelf alongside other decorative objects. Available in three sizes, from 2.4 by 4.5 inches to 3.9 by 7.3 inches, it's currently on sale from $8.99 and up.

A more modern change from the typical cylindrical candle holder, the Copper & Glass Hurricane Candle Holder features a hexagonal footprint formed by a gold-toned copper frame and glass panels. Sized to hold pillars, these holders are available in three sizes, with sale prices ranging from $10.19 to $17.99. Best of all, it's neutral enough for year-round use, so you don't have to stash it away after the holidays.

If you worry about children or pets knocking over decorative glass trees, Michaels offers less fragile alternatives, such as the Tinsel Ball Tabletop Tree, which is made of plastic, polyfoam, and polyester. With attention-grabbing, shimmering pompoms, the tree comes in four sizes, from 1 foot to 30 inches tall. Currently, it's on sale starting at $13.49. 

Lighting the dinner table just got more stylish thanks to the Jonathan Adler x Michaels 10-Inch Taper Candles, which feature a stacked geometric design. Beautiful for Hanukkah or general winter decor, they come in a set of three — one each in dark blue, light blue, and gold — with a price tag of $14.99.