The One Rare Vintage Mug You Should Never Pass Up At Estate Sales Or Thrift Stores

We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.

Estate sales are like treasure hunts with a touch of history. Imagine stepping into someone's home and uncovering vintage furniture, retro glassware, or art that tells a story you can bring into your own space. Unlike a typical yard sale, estate sales open the door to entire households, where every room holds a chance to find something personal and unexpected. And, every so often, you stumble on a rare gem you should never overlook, not only because of its value, but also for its sheer charm. Case in point: the Sigma Muppets mugs and egg cups from 1978. These whimsical pieces, featuring beloved Muppet characters like Animal, Miss Piggy, and, of course, Kermit the Frog, are the kind of nostalgic finds that make collectors' hearts say "Hi-Ho" and kitchen shelves infinitely happier.

As one commenter on Facebook says, "I found Kermit on a random shelf at a flea market and immediately purchased [it]. Best purchase I've ever made." Why should you keep your eyes peeled for these? Because some are fetching over $200 on eBay — like the Dr. Teeth mug currently listed for a cool $234.99 on eBay or the Gonzo mug (the most elusive of the bunch), going for $499.99 on eBay. According to YouTube's Texas Gal Treasures, "There's a huge fan base for Muppets, especially the Dr. Teeth mug," which she says will only increase once the Rock 'n' Roller Coaster at Disney's Hollywood Studio is rethemed as a Muppets coaster by summer 2026. 

Sigma Muppets mugs hold their value because they capture a perfect mix of nostalgia, artistry, and scarcity. Made by Sigma the Tastesetter in the late 1970s and early 1980s, these hand-painted ceramic mugs were licensed during Jim Henson's golden era, giving them instant collectible status. There was an initial set featuring Kermit the Frog, Miss Piggy, Fozzie Bear, and Rowlf the Dog, followed by a second set featuring Gonzo, Animal, and Dr. Teeth. The company also produced a set of Muppet egg cups in Statler, Waldorf, Sam the Eagle, and Zoot figures, which, as a set, can sell for $159.99 to $219.99 on eBay. Each one was crafted in Japan or Korea, and, as with any vintage item, their limited supply only makes them more desirable.

Certain mugs, however, are more valuable than others. While it's not easy being green, or finding a mint-condition Kermit mug from 1978, characters like Gonzo and Dr. Teeth might be worth the hunt, using these secrets to find vintage treasures, because they tend to fetch higher prices because of their rarity and cult-favorite status. Meanwhile, the core four (Kermit, Miss Piggy, Fozzie, and Rowlf) often sell for relatively affordable prices, but a complete, mint-condition set can go for more. Chips or cracks will obviously diminish value. Eager to use these mugs as home decor instead of for coffee? Here are 16 genius ways to reuse coffee mugs.