Planting common milkweed (Asclepias syriaca) in your yard attracts monarch butterflies, but it can also become weedy from self-seeding. If you've grown tired of this native plant growing in your yard, or just want to reduce how much you have growing, you can get rid of it by hand pulling or spraying with weedkiller. Common milkweed is slightly toxic when eaten in large quantities and can cause rashes in some people when its milky sap touches the skin, so protect yourself by wearing gloves, long sleeves and long pants when working with the plant.

Monarch butterfly feeding on milkweed
credit: orthogon/iStock/Getty Images
Milkweed is an important food source for monarch butterflies.

Mow Before Pods Form

Common milkweed grows in U. S. Department of Agriculture plant hardiness zones 4 through 9, can grow up to 6 feet tall, and produces seed pods up to 5 inches long. In late summer and fall, these pods split open, spewing seeds that re-seed the plant. One way to kill common milkweed is to mow it every two to three weeks before the seed pods form. Mowing weakens the plant and eventually the plant dies. If the milkweed plants have seed pods before the first mowing, cut the plants near the bases, using pruning shears, and collect the debris to dispose of with the rest of your yard waste. Make sure no seed pods fall on the ground where they can sprout new plants. After pruning the plants, mow every three weeks until the plants die.

Pull by Hand

Common milkweed spreads through seed dispersal, but also through underground rhizomes. When the rhizomes are severed during rototilling or hoeing, a new plant forms from each segment. To reduce the risk of severing rhizomes, hand pull the entire plant, including the roots. Pull out as much of the rhizome as possible. The best time to pull plants is when they are young and before the roots are deeply established. If the pulled plants don't have seed pods, lay them out in a thin layer to dry for about 10 days then add them to a compost pile. Drying the plants reduces the risk that they'll grow back.

Spray When Budding

If common milkweed is growing in a garden area without lawn, kill it by thoroughly spraying the leaves with a ready-to-use herbicide containing glyphosate. Keep in mind glyphosate kills any plant it comes in contact with, including flowering plants, shrubs and grass, and can harm butterflies feeding on sprayed plants. Only use glyphosate where it won't touch the plants you want to keep and on a calm day to prevent drift onto desirable plants. The most effective time to spray common milkweed is when the plant is dry, actively growing and buds have formed. At this stage, glyphosate travels to the roots, quicker, where it kills the plant. Wear eye protection, gloves, long sleeves, long pants, socks and sturdy shoes when working with herbicides. Follow all warnings on the product label and keep children and pets out of the area until the spray has dried.

Shade Out

You can prevent milkweed from re-sprouting by spreading a 3- to 4-inch layer of mulch over the area where milkweed was removed. Common milkweed needs plenty of sun to grow and shading keeps it from growing. Growing a thick stand of flowering plants or shrubs also helps to shade out milkweed from regrowing.